
歷經(jīng)四周64場(chǎng)比賽和十多年的爭(zhēng)議,阿根廷在卡塔爾贏得了國(guó)際足聯(lián)男子世界杯冠軍,。在梅西和他的隊(duì)友慶祝戰(zhàn)勝法國(guó)隊(duì)的同時(shí),,另一場(chǎng)比賽也落下了帷幕:“軟實(shí)力”之戰(zhàn)。
軟實(shí)力是一種外交政策工具,,利用音樂(lè),、時(shí)尚和體育等事物來(lái)塑造全球認(rèn)知和心態(tài)。國(guó)際足聯(lián)世界杯也許是終極軟實(shí)力平臺(tái),,有32個(gè)國(guó)家向數(shù)十億人展示他們的軟實(shí)力,。
在賽事期間,,可以觀察到三種類(lèi)型的軟實(shí)力:“輝煌”軟實(shí)力,來(lái)自高水平的表現(xiàn),,不由讓人產(chǎn)生欽佩之情,;“美麗”軟實(shí)力,激發(fā)了希望和團(tuán)結(jié)意識(shí),;以及“良性”軟實(shí)力,,體現(xiàn)在積極的態(tài)度和利他主義中。
利用這些類(lèi)別,,我們確定了2022年“軟實(shí)力世界杯”的國(guó)家排名,。
冠軍:法國(guó)
在全球軟實(shí)力排名中,法國(guó)的排名因在2018年俄羅斯世界杯上奪冠而上升,。在2022年世界杯上,,法國(guó)隊(duì)的表現(xiàn)推動(dòng)法國(guó)國(guó)家形象和聲譽(yù)進(jìn)一步提升。這支球隊(duì)是“輝煌”軟實(shí)力的縮影,,將風(fēng)格和優(yōu)雅與靈敏和競(jìng)爭(zhēng)力相結(jié)合,,并展現(xiàn)出國(guó)際化、多元化和團(tuán)結(jié)的形象,。
一名球員(可以說(shuō)是目前世界上最好的球員)在這方面發(fā)揮了重要作用:基利安·姆巴佩(Kylian Mbappé),。他效力于巴黎圣日耳曼足球俱樂(lè)部(PSG),該俱樂(lè)部是法國(guó)軟實(shí)力故事的重要組成部分,。在精心管理下,,通過(guò)足球、時(shí)尚和音樂(lè)的結(jié)合,,幫助法國(guó)塑造了良好聲譽(yù),。
據(jù)報(bào)道,今年早些時(shí)候,,法國(guó)總統(tǒng)埃馬紐埃爾·馬克龍(Emmanuel Macron)出面勸說(shuō)姆巴佩不要離開(kāi)巴黎圣日耳曼轉(zhuǎn)會(huì)皇馬(Real Madrid),,這就是他對(duì)法國(guó)的重要性。在全球事務(wù)中需要魅力,、風(fēng)格和自信,馬克龍對(duì)這一點(diǎn)深信不疑,。法國(guó)隊(duì)進(jìn)入半決賽后,,他飛往多哈,會(huì)見(jiàn)了卡塔爾埃米爾,。在決賽的全場(chǎng)比賽中,,他反復(fù)安慰姆巴佩。
亞軍:韓國(guó)
憑借“鼓舞人心”的軟實(shí)力,,韓國(guó)的足球明星效應(yīng)持續(xù)升溫,。這部分是政府實(shí)施的政策帶來(lái)的結(jié)果,,另一方面也是私營(yíng)部門(mén)高漲的愛(ài)國(guó)主義帶來(lái)的結(jié)果。
韓國(guó)隊(duì)的首場(chǎng)比賽是在歌手田柾國(guó)(Jung Kook)出席開(kāi)幕式之后進(jìn)行的,。田柾國(guó)是防彈少年團(tuán)(BTS)的歌手,,該樂(lè)隊(duì)一直處于被稱(chēng)為“韓流”(或K-wave)的前沿,使韓國(guó)在電影,、電視和音樂(lè)領(lǐng)域處于全球舞臺(tái)的中心,。汽車(chē)制造商現(xiàn)代起亞也與田柾國(guó)進(jìn)行了合作,該公司與防彈少年團(tuán)簽訂了代言協(xié)議,,也是國(guó)際足聯(lián)(FIFA)的主要贊助商,。
韓國(guó)也很幸運(yùn),他們實(shí)力最強(qiáng)的球員——托特納姆熱刺隊(duì)(Tottenham Hotspur)的孫興慜傷愈復(fù)出,,為球隊(duì)贏得了全球認(rèn)可,。韓國(guó)人揮灑自如的比賽風(fēng)格,再加上熱情洋溢的球迷,,完美地展現(xiàn)了國(guó)家能量,,使其成為21世紀(jì)流行文化巨頭。
第三名:摩洛哥
由于賽前足球排名落后于前20名,,在大型賽事中表現(xiàn)不佳,,沒(méi)有大牌球員,人們的期望并不高,。但這屆世界杯對(duì)摩洛哥來(lái)說(shuō)是一場(chǎng)勝利,,無(wú)論是場(chǎng)上還是場(chǎng)下。
球隊(duì)歡快的氛圍,、無(wú)拘無(wú)束的比賽方式產(chǎn)生了相當(dāng)大的軟實(shí)力價(jià)值,,個(gè)別球員也是如此。中場(chǎng)球員索菲亞內(nèi)·鮑法爾(Sofiane Boufal)在球隊(duì)?wèi)?zhàn)勝葡萄牙隊(duì)后與母親在球場(chǎng)上跳舞的場(chǎng)面,,是令人信服的家庭和團(tuán)結(jié)的行為,,引起了世界各地人們的共鳴。許多人后來(lái)將阿特拉斯雄獅隊(duì)(Atlas Lions)作為他們第二喜愛(ài)的球隊(duì),。
這一點(diǎn)在阿拉伯世界表現(xiàn)得最為明顯,,摩洛哥比以往任何一支來(lái)自中東或北非的球隊(duì)都走得更遠(yuǎn)。摩洛哥球員對(duì)巴勒斯坦的公開(kāi)支持也幫助球隊(duì)與該地區(qū)的球迷建立了聯(lián)系,。
第四名:日本
日本隊(duì)在卡塔爾收獲了大量新球迷,。就像2018年世界杯一樣,大批日本球迷抵達(dá)現(xiàn)場(chǎng),,并再次主動(dòng)承擔(dān)了賽后場(chǎng)館的清理工作,。作為“良性”軟實(shí)力的冠軍,日本國(guó)家隊(duì)還在賽后清理了更衣室。
整理內(nèi)務(wù)在日本是有悠久歷史的,。早在近藤麻理惠(Marie Kondo)上臺(tái)之前,,整理和清潔就已經(jīng)是日本文化結(jié)構(gòu)的一部分??ㄋ柕馁惡笄謇砉ぷ鲝?qiáng)化了這一流行慣例,,并彰顯了其軟實(shí)力潛力。
但這次比賽不僅僅展示了該國(guó)的利他主義行為,。這支球隊(duì)在對(duì)陣德國(guó)和西班牙這兩個(gè)歐洲足球超級(jí)大國(guó)的比賽中取得了驚人的勝利,。
第五名:沙特阿拉伯
“綠色獵鷹”作為一個(gè)被廣泛視為賤民的國(guó)家的代表前往卡塔爾。雖然這支球隊(duì)在小組賽階段就出局了,,但它在這個(gè)過(guò)程中贏得了人心,。
大量球迷來(lái)到了多哈,他們?cè)诒荣惽暗木奂癸@了這支球隊(duì)的吸引力,。社交媒體上一個(gè)瘋傳的帖子顯示,,在沙特阿拉伯擊敗最終的冠軍阿根廷后,大批支持者伴著1996年的流行歌曲跳起舞來(lái),,這進(jìn)一步提升了該球隊(duì)的吸引力,。
盡管人們對(duì)沙特阿拉伯的政治陰謀仍有擔(dān)憂(yōu)(尤其是對(duì)其體育洗白(舉辦運(yùn)動(dòng)賽事來(lái)提高國(guó)家聲譽(yù))的指控),這是合乎情理的,,但卡塔爾主辦的賽事展示了沙特公民積極的,、與眾不同的一面。對(duì)足球的全民熱情讓遠(yuǎn)道而來(lái)的球迷感到沙特公民很有人情味,。
特別提名獎(jiǎng):卡塔爾
從提交申辦世界杯的那一刻起,,卡塔爾就一直在尋求投射軟實(shí)力。這個(gè)國(guó)家的熱情好客,,沒(méi)有足球流氓暴力,,以及充滿(mǎn)活力的球迷區(qū)似乎對(duì)它很有利。
但它也可能發(fā)現(xiàn)自己被剝奪了權(quán)力,,因?yàn)槿藗儗?duì)移民工人和性少數(shù)群體權(quán)利的擔(dān)憂(yōu)仍然存在,。考驗(yàn)將是人們?cè)谖磥?lái)幾年如何談?wù)摽ㄋ栠@個(gè)國(guó)家和它主辦的賽事,。不過(guò),,就目前而言,盡管球員和球迷可能感覺(jué)不到這一點(diǎn),,但軟實(shí)力的大贏家屬于法國(guó),。(財(cái)富中文網(wǎng))
西蒙·查德威克(Simon Chadwick), SKEMA商學(xué)院體育和地緣政治經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)教授,保羅·維多普(Paul Widdop),,曼徹斯特大學(xué)體育商業(yè)研究員。
本文以創(chuàng)作共用協(xié)議的形式轉(zhuǎn)載自The Conversation。
譯者:中慧言-王芳
歷經(jīng)四周64場(chǎng)比賽和十多年的爭(zhēng)議,,阿根廷在卡塔爾贏得了國(guó)際足聯(lián)男子世界杯冠軍,。在梅西和他的隊(duì)友慶祝戰(zhàn)勝法國(guó)隊(duì)的同時(shí),另一場(chǎng)比賽也落下了帷幕:“軟實(shí)力”之戰(zhàn),。
軟實(shí)力是一種外交政策工具,,利用音樂(lè)、時(shí)尚和體育等事物來(lái)塑造全球認(rèn)知和心態(tài),。國(guó)際足聯(lián)世界杯也許是終極軟實(shí)力平臺(tái),,有32個(gè)國(guó)家向數(shù)十億人展示他們的軟實(shí)力。
在賽事期間,,可以觀察到三種類(lèi)型的軟實(shí)力:“輝煌”軟實(shí)力,,來(lái)自高水平的表現(xiàn),不由讓人產(chǎn)生欽佩之情,;“美麗”軟實(shí)力,,激發(fā)了希望和團(tuán)結(jié)意識(shí);以及“良性”軟實(shí)力,,體現(xiàn)在積極的態(tài)度和利他主義中,。
利用這些類(lèi)別,我們確定了2022年“軟實(shí)力世界杯”的國(guó)家排名,。
冠軍:法國(guó)
在全球軟實(shí)力排名中,,法國(guó)的排名因在2018年俄羅斯世界杯上奪冠而上升。在2022年世界杯上,,法國(guó)隊(duì)的表現(xiàn)推動(dòng)法國(guó)國(guó)家形象和聲譽(yù)進(jìn)一步提升,。這支球隊(duì)是“輝煌”軟實(shí)力的縮影,將風(fēng)格和優(yōu)雅與靈敏和競(jìng)爭(zhēng)力相結(jié)合,,并展現(xiàn)出國(guó)際化,、多元化和團(tuán)結(jié)的形象。
一名球員(可以說(shuō)是目前世界上最好的球員)在這方面發(fā)揮了重要作用:基利安·姆巴佩(Kylian Mbappé),。他效力于巴黎圣日耳曼足球俱樂(lè)部(PSG),,該俱樂(lè)部是法國(guó)軟實(shí)力故事的重要組成部分。在精心管理下,,通過(guò)足球,、時(shí)尚和音樂(lè)的結(jié)合,幫助法國(guó)塑造了良好聲譽(yù),。
據(jù)報(bào)道,,今年早些時(shí)候,法國(guó)總統(tǒng)埃馬紐埃爾·馬克龍(Emmanuel Macron)出面勸說(shuō)姆巴佩不要離開(kāi)巴黎圣日耳曼轉(zhuǎn)會(huì)皇馬(Real Madrid),,這就是他對(duì)法國(guó)的重要性,。在全球事務(wù)中需要魅力、風(fēng)格和自信,馬克龍對(duì)這一點(diǎn)深信不疑,。法國(guó)隊(duì)進(jìn)入半決賽后,,他飛往多哈,會(huì)見(jiàn)了卡塔爾埃米爾,。在決賽的全場(chǎng)比賽中,,他反復(fù)安慰姆巴佩。
亞軍:韓國(guó)
憑借“鼓舞人心”的軟實(shí)力,,韓國(guó)的足球明星效應(yīng)持續(xù)升溫,。這部分是政府實(shí)施的政策帶來(lái)的結(jié)果,另一方面也是私營(yíng)部門(mén)高漲的愛(ài)國(guó)主義帶來(lái)的結(jié)果,。
韓國(guó)隊(duì)的首場(chǎng)比賽是在歌手田柾國(guó)(Jung Kook)出席開(kāi)幕式之后進(jìn)行的,。田柾國(guó)是防彈少年團(tuán)(BTS)的歌手,該樂(lè)隊(duì)一直處于被稱(chēng)為“韓流”(或K-wave)的前沿,,使韓國(guó)在電影,、電視和音樂(lè)領(lǐng)域處于全球舞臺(tái)的中心。汽車(chē)制造商現(xiàn)代起亞也與田柾國(guó)進(jìn)行了合作,,該公司與防彈少年團(tuán)簽訂了代言協(xié)議,,也是國(guó)際足聯(lián)(FIFA)的主要贊助商。
韓國(guó)也很幸運(yùn),,他們實(shí)力最強(qiáng)的球員——托特納姆熱刺隊(duì)(Tottenham Hotspur)的孫興慜傷愈復(fù)出,,為球隊(duì)贏得了全球認(rèn)可。韓國(guó)人揮灑自如的比賽風(fēng)格,,再加上熱情洋溢的球迷,,完美地展現(xiàn)了國(guó)家能量,使其成為21世紀(jì)流行文化巨頭,。
第三名:摩洛哥
由于賽前足球排名落后于前20名,,在大型賽事中表現(xiàn)不佳,沒(méi)有大牌球員,,人們的期望并不高,。但這屆世界杯對(duì)摩洛哥來(lái)說(shuō)是一場(chǎng)勝利,無(wú)論是場(chǎng)上還是場(chǎng)下,。
球隊(duì)歡快的氛圍,、無(wú)拘無(wú)束的比賽方式產(chǎn)生了相當(dāng)大的軟實(shí)力價(jià)值,個(gè)別球員也是如此,。中場(chǎng)球員索菲亞內(nèi)·鮑法爾(Sofiane Boufal)在球隊(duì)?wèi)?zhàn)勝葡萄牙隊(duì)后與母親在球場(chǎng)上跳舞的場(chǎng)面,,是令人信服的家庭和團(tuán)結(jié)的行為,引起了世界各地人們的共鳴,。許多人后來(lái)將阿特拉斯雄獅隊(duì)(Atlas Lions)作為他們第二喜愛(ài)的球隊(duì),。
這一點(diǎn)在阿拉伯世界表現(xiàn)得最為明顯,,摩洛哥比以往任何一支來(lái)自中東或北非的球隊(duì)都走得更遠(yuǎn)。摩洛哥球員對(duì)巴勒斯坦的公開(kāi)支持也幫助球隊(duì)與該地區(qū)的球迷建立了聯(lián)系,。
第四名:日本
日本隊(duì)在卡塔爾收獲了大量新球迷,。就像2018年世界杯一樣,大批日本球迷抵達(dá)現(xiàn)場(chǎng),,并再次主動(dòng)承擔(dān)了賽后場(chǎng)館的清理工作。作為“良性”軟實(shí)力的冠軍,,日本國(guó)家隊(duì)還在賽后清理了更衣室,。
整理內(nèi)務(wù)在日本是有悠久歷史的。早在近藤麻理惠(Marie Kondo)上臺(tái)之前,,整理和清潔就已經(jīng)是日本文化結(jié)構(gòu)的一部分,。卡塔爾的賽后清理工作強(qiáng)化了這一流行慣例,,并彰顯了其軟實(shí)力潛力,。
但這次比賽不僅僅展示了該國(guó)的利他主義行為。這支球隊(duì)在對(duì)陣德國(guó)和西班牙這兩個(gè)歐洲足球超級(jí)大國(guó)的比賽中取得了驚人的勝利,。
第五名:沙特阿拉伯
“綠色獵鷹”作為一個(gè)被廣泛視為賤民的國(guó)家的代表前往卡塔爾,。雖然這支球隊(duì)在小組賽階段就出局了,但它在這個(gè)過(guò)程中贏得了人心,。
大量球迷來(lái)到了多哈,,他們?cè)诒荣惽暗木奂癸@了這支球隊(duì)的吸引力。社交媒體上一個(gè)瘋傳的帖子顯示,,在沙特阿拉伯擊敗最終的冠軍阿根廷后,,大批支持者伴著1996年的流行歌曲跳起舞來(lái),這進(jìn)一步提升了該球隊(duì)的吸引力,。
盡管人們對(duì)沙特阿拉伯的政治陰謀仍有擔(dān)憂(yōu)(尤其是對(duì)其體育洗白(舉辦運(yùn)動(dòng)賽事來(lái)提高國(guó)家聲譽(yù))的指控),,這是合乎情理的,但卡塔爾主辦的賽事展示了沙特公民積極的,、與眾不同的一面,。對(duì)足球的全民熱情讓遠(yuǎn)道而來(lái)的球迷感到沙特公民很有人情味。
特別提名獎(jiǎng):卡塔爾
從提交申辦世界杯的那一刻起,,卡塔爾就一直在尋求投射軟實(shí)力,。這個(gè)國(guó)家的熱情好客,沒(méi)有足球流氓暴力,,以及充滿(mǎn)活力的球迷區(qū)似乎對(duì)它很有利,。
但它也可能發(fā)現(xiàn)自己被剝奪了權(quán)力,因?yàn)槿藗儗?duì)移民工人和性少數(shù)群體權(quán)利的擔(dān)憂(yōu)仍然存在,??简?yàn)將是人們?cè)谖磥?lái)幾年如何談?wù)摽ㄋ栠@個(gè)國(guó)家和它主辦的賽事,。不過(guò),就目前而言,,盡管球員和球迷可能感覺(jué)不到這一點(diǎn),,但軟實(shí)力的大贏家屬于法國(guó)。(財(cái)富中文網(wǎng))
西蒙·查德威克(Simon Chadwick), SKEMA商學(xué)院體育和地緣政治經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)教授,,保羅·維多普(Paul Widdop),,曼徹斯特大學(xué)體育商業(yè)研究員。
本文以創(chuàng)作共用協(xié)議的形式轉(zhuǎn)載自The Conversation,。
譯者:中慧言-王芳
After four weeks, 64 games, and more than a decade of controversy, Argentina has won the Fifa men’s World Cup in Qatar. And as Lionel Messi and his teammates celebrate victory over France, another competition has also reached its conclusion: the battle for “soft power.”
Soft power is a foreign policy tool. It’s about shaping global perceptions and attitudes using things like music, fashion, and sport. The Fifa World Cup is perhaps the ultimate soft power platform, with 32 countries on show to billions of people.
During the event, three types of soft power could be observed: “brilliant” soft power, which comes from high performance levels and generates feelings of admiration; “beautiful” soft power, which inspires hope and a sense of togetherness; and “benign” soft power, which is found in positive attitudes and altruism.
Using these categories we have determined the following national placings for the 2022 “World Cup of Soft Power.”
Winners: France
In global soft power rankings, France was lifted by its win at the 2018 Fifa World Cup in Russia. In 2022, the football team’s performances have only strengthened the national image and reputation. The squad is the epitome of “brilliant” soft power, combining style and elegance with acute competitiveness, and projecting an image that is cosmopolitan, diverse, and united.
One player (arguably the world’s best right now) is instrumental in this: Kylian Mbappé. His club side, Paris Saint Germain (PSG), is a big part of France’s soft power story, helping to build its credentials through a carefully managed combination of football, fashion, and music.
Earlier this year, French president Emmanuel Macron reportedly stepped in to persuade Mbappé not to leave PSG for Real Madrid, such is his importance to France. Macron fully understands the need for charm, style, and confidence in global affairs. When he flew to Doha after France had made it to the semifinals, he met the emir of Qatar. At full time in the final, he repeatedly consoled Mbappé.
Runner-up: South Korea
Masters of “inspirational” soft power, South Korea’s star continues to rise. This is partly a result of government policy, but also the private sector’s enthusiastic patriotism.
South Korea’s first match at the tournament came after an appearance by the singer Jung Kook at the opening ceremony. Kook is a singer with BTS, a band that has been at the forefront of what has become known as the “Korean wave” (or K-wave), which put the country center stage globally in cinema, television, and music. In tandem with Kook came the carmaker Hyundai-Kia, which has an endorsement deal with BTS and is also a key Fifa sponsor.
South Korea was also lucky to have its biggest player—Tottenham Hotspur’s Son Heung-min—back from injury, bringing global recognition to the squad. The Koreans’ swashbuckling style of play, matched by exuberant fans, tapped perfectly into a national energy, which has seen it become a juggernaut of 21st-century popular culture.
Third place: Morocco
With a pre-competition football ranking below the top 20, a history of underperformance in big tournaments, and no big-name players, expectations were not high. But this World Cup has turned out to be a triumph for Morocco, on and off the pitch.
The joyous, uninhibited way in which the team competed generated considerable soft power value, as did some of the individual players. The sight of midfielder Sofiane Boufal dancing on the pitch with his mother after his side’s victory over Portugal was a compelling act of family and togetherness that has resonated with people around the world. Many subsequently adopted the Atlas Lions as their second favorite team. https://www.youtube.com/embed/l1AOzi0MXNo?wmode=transparent&start=2
https://www.youtube.com/embed/l1AOzi0MXNo?wmode=transparent&start=2
Nowhere was this more evident than across the Arab world, Morocco having progressed further than any other previous team from the Middle East or North Africa. The Moroccan players’ public support for Palestine also helped the team bond with fans from across the region.
Fourth place: Japan
Japan won plenty of new fans in Qatar. Just like at the 2018 tournament, Japanese supporters arrived in huge numbers, and again took it upon themselves to undertake post-match tidy-ups of the stadiums. Adding to their position as champions of “benign” soft power, the Japanese national team also cleaned their changing rooms after their matches.
Tidying up has history in Japan. Long before Marie Kondo arrived on the scene, de-cluttering and cleaning were part of the national cultural fabric. Tidying up in Qatar reinforced this popular convention and harnessed its soft power potential.
But the tournament wasn’t just about acts of altruism. The team celebrated stunning victories against two of Europe’s football superpowers, Germany and Spain.
Fifth place: Saudi Arabia
The Green Falcons headed to Qatar as representatives of a nation widely viewed as a pariah. And although the team went out at the group stage, it won many hearts and minds in the process.
A huge number of fans made it to Doha, their congregation before matches highlighting their appeal. This was further enhanced with a viral social media post showing large numbers of supporters dancing to a 1996 pop song after Saudi Arabia beat the eventual champions, Argentina.
And while legitimate concerns remain about Saudi Arabia’s political machinations (not least accusations of sportswashing), events in Qatar showed Saudi citizens in a different and positive light. The traveling fans were humanized by their national passion for football.
Special mention: Qatar
From the very moment it submitted its bid to host the World Cup, Qatar has sought to project soft power. The country’s hospitality, the absence of hooligan violence, and the vibrant fan zones appear to have worked in its favor.
But it may also find itself disempowered, as concerns about migrant workers and LGBTQ+ rights remain. The test will be how Qatar the nation and the event it hosted are talked about in the years to come. For now, though, although it may not feel like it for the players and fans, the big soft power win belongs to France.
Simon Chadwick, professor of sport and geopolitical economy, SKEMA Business School, and Paul Widdop, researcher of sport business, University of Manchester.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.